CALIFORNIA UCP CAPITOL REPORT #92-2003
July 1, 2003 - Tuesday
ASSEMBLY REPUBLICAN BUDGET PROPOSAL CALLS FOR MAJOR CUTS TO
HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES; SOME REPORTS OF POSSIBLE BUDGET DEAL
IN SENATE
A budget proposal put together by Assembly Republicans, which
calls for major additional cuts to education, health and human
services programs, including those impacting people with
disabilities will be considered in the Assembly as early as
Wednesday morning (7/2). At this point, it is unlikely the
Assembly Democrats will back the Assembly Republican plan.
Governor Davis, in a press conference this afternoon (7/1)
said he would not sign the Republican plan if passed.
Meanwhile, there are conflicting reports that a possible
budget deal is near in the Senate, though no details are
available. The Senate is scheduled possibly to meet on
Wednesday sometime to take up the budget. Senate Republicans
were possibly going to present a series of amendments to the
Senate Democratic budget proposal, that failed passage last
week, on Thursday - though this may change if a reports of a
budget deal are true.
The Assembly Republican budget proposal, originally released
April 28, used the Governor Davis' proposed budget he
submitted January 10, as the base for additional cuts, though
this doesn't appear to be the case in all instances. The
Assembly Republican budget proposal updated, revised and
released yesterday adds many additional cuts to health and
human services, though in many cases it is not clear if they
were reversing actions in the Assembly Democratic proposal
from last week that restored many cuts, or adding to the cuts
proposed in the revision of the proposed budget that the
Governor released in May.
The Assembly Republican plan proposes additional major cuts,
extends the financing of a $10 billion portion of the state's
deficit from 5 to 6 years, and makes other reductions and
savings without raising taxes or triggering the increases of
vehicle license fees as a means to close the staggering state
budget shortfall.
"Assembly Republicans are not interested in wasting any more
time or taxpayer money responding to political 'drills'"
Assembly Republican Leader Dave Cox (R-Fair Oaks) said, adding
that "...this proposal represents a balanced solution that
solves the problem."
Many Democrats, including Assemblywoman Judy Chu (D-Monterey
Park, 49th District) were critical of the proposal that
contained major cuts to health and human programs and
services. Advocates for people with disabilities, seniors,
and people with low-incomes, while happy that the Republican
proposal restored cuts to Medi-Cal providers that the Governor
proposed in January, were also sharply critical of what they
viewed as "staggering deep cuts" to critically needed services
and programs.
Reportedly some elements of the Assembly Republican plan are
also in the Senate Republican proposal, including limits on
regional center spending, and statewide standards for the
regional center budget that funds community-based services and
supports (purchase of services) for people with developmental
disabilities. The Assembly Republican plan also calls for an
additional 15% cut in state operations, phased in, resulting
in a reduction in 2003-04 of $400,000,000. There were no
details how this would be achieved or specific impacts to each
department, including Department of Developmental Services or
Department of Rehabilitation or the Departments of Health
Services (Medi-Cal) or Social Services (IHSS and SSI/SSP
programs).
SUMMARY OF MAJOR CUTS IN ASSEMBLY REPUBLICAN PROPOSAL
IMPACTING PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES:
The Assembly Republican proposal released yesterday, calls for
additional cuts for the 2003-2005 budget year (these cuts are
in most cases in ADDITION to the cuts already proposed by the
Governor - or in some cases, apparently in addition to the
cuts proposed in the Assembly Democratic budget proposal. In
some instances it is not clear. [note: it is not clear what
the Assembly Republicans used as their baseline, since in some
cases they refer (when they first released the proposal in
April) that the cuts were in addition to the Governor's
January proposed budget, yet in other cases it appears the
Assembly Republicans were simply reversing actions made
recently by the Democrats (proposing a cut that was less than
the Governor's January proposal, but more than the May Revise,
and different from the Assembly Democratic proposed
reduction).
COMMUNITY-BASED SERVICES FOR PEOPLE WITH DEVELOPMENTAL
DISABILITIES
Note: Presumably these cuts are in addition to the narrowing
of eligibility standards, parental co-payments, and presumably
cuts to program and service freezes, and cuts to regional
center operations, cuts to Habilitation Services (work
activity and supported employment) in the Governor's proposed
budget in January and the May Revision (it is not clear in
some instances below). Implementation of purchase of service
standards would - many advocates believe, result in the
suspension or even elimination of the basic civil rights of
people with developmental disabilities contained in the "Lanterman
Developmental Disabilities Services Act". The impact,
according to advocates, would be enormous, resulting in huge
cuts to critically needed services. The proposed spending cap
- or expenditure limit would have a devastating impact -
especially in the area of children with autism, where caseload
growth has exploded in the last 5 years.
* Regional Center statewide purchase of service standards
Cut: -$50 million (2003-2004, though it is not really clear if
this amount replaces the $10 million cut proposed by Assembly
Democrats last week, or if its in addition to the Governor's
proposed $70 million cut, as proposed in May)
* Expenditure limits on regional center purchase of services
Cut: -$97 million (2003-2004)
* Early Start funding shift from Department of Developmental
Services to funding under Proposition 98 (the constitutional
provision that guarantees a minimum funding for education)
Note: this is not a cut to the early intervention program, but
it would presumably reduce spending ($59 million for 2003-04)
within the education budget for other K-12 programs.
MEDI-CAL AND HEALTH
Note: the Assembly Republican proposal rejects the Governor's
proposal to cut Medi-Cal provider rates and restores that
funding (already in the Assembly Democratic and Senate
Democratic budget plans) and also rejects the Governor's
proposal to eliminate Medi-Cal dental and durable medical
equipment optional benefits. The proposed elimination of the
other optional benefits however impact people with
disabilities, though the other cuts to Medi-Cal impact
primarily people with low incomes (including seniors).
* Elimination of Medi-Cal optional benefits, except for
durable medical equipment and dental
* Restriction of Medi-Cal dental benefits to $1,000 per year
Cut: -$6 million
* New Medi-Cal recipients who have disabilities to enroll in
managed care programs
Cut: -$1 million
* New Medi-Cal recipients who are seniors to enroll in managed
care programs
Cut: -$69 million
* Other reductions include reinstatement of quarterly status
reports (-$43 million); rescind continuous Healthy Families
eligibility for children (-$76 million); eliminate accelerated
enrollment/Healthy Families bridge (-$6 million); exclude over
the counter drugs from Medi-Cal coverage (-$8 million); Medi-Cal
co-payments; rescind Healthy Families eligibility expansion
[return back to 200% of the Federal Poverty Level] (-$56
million); many other state only Medi-Cal programs including
Medi-Cal Dialysis Only and Dialysis Supplemental (-$341,000);
Minor Consent Services (-$786,000); Medically Indigent Long
Term Care (-$38,928,000); State Funded Abortions (-$27
million); and also the Children's Medical Services Branch
Genetically Handicapped Persons Program (-$34,680,000); the
Primary and Rural Health Care Systems' Rural Health Services
Development Program (-$8,203,000); Indian Health Program
(-$6,484,000); Rural Demonstration Project/Healthy Families
Program (-$3 million); Child Health and Disability Prevention
(-$50,634,000); Seasonal Agricultural and Migratory Workers
Program (-$6,871,000); Family pact pROGRAM (-$63,462,000).
SUPPLEMENTAL SECURITY INCOME/STATE SUPPLEMENTAL PAYMENT (SSI/SSP)
Note: these cuts are in addition to the suspension of the cost
of living adjustments for SSI/SSP in the Assembly Democratic
budget proposal. The Assembly Republican proposal would also
freeze CalWORKS cost of living adjustments for 3 years.
Advocates claim that the cut to the "federal maintenance of
effort" would be devastating to seniors, people with
developmental and other disabilities, especially when coupled
with the suspension of any cost of living adjustments.
* Reduces SSI/SSP grants to the federal "maintenance of
effort" level
Cut: $-497 million
* Eliminates of SSP cost of living adjustment for 2004-2005
(and possibly longer) Note: presumably this is in addition to
the Governor's freeze
Cut: $77 million (2004-2005 budget year and possibly beyond)
SENIOR PROGRAMS
Note: the proposal would reject the Governor's proposed
elimination of senior nutrition programs, but the moratorium
on new adult day health centers, rejected by the Assembly
Democrats earlier, is a serious reduction that was proposed by
the Governor in May.
* Moratorium on new adult day health centers
Cut: -$21 million
IN-HOME SUPPORTIVE SERVICES (IHSS)
Note: While not impacting 2003-04 budget year, the freeze on
providing state funds for IHSS wage increases for 2004-05
would have a tremendous impact on IHSS workers across the
state.
* Freeze the state's portion of IHSS wage increases for
2004-05 budget year
Cut: -$57 million (2004-05 budget year)
* Eliminates the state only Medi-Cal Substantial Gainful
Activity for aged, blind and disabled, medically needy program
Cut: -$195,100
WHAT DOES THIS ALL MEAN
* At this point, nothing, since it is highly unlikely the
Assembly Republican proposal - as it stands now with
additional deep cuts to health and human services, has any
hope of passage tomorrow. However there may be possible areas
of compromise (also in the Senate Republican budget proposal)
that could lead to some budget deal - more likely in the
Senate, as previously reported - especially with the rumors
flying of a reported possible budget deal there.
NEXT STEPS
* SENATE: No floor session today (Tuesday), but conflicting
reports that a possible budget deal is near in the Senate.
Possible floor session scheduled for tomorrow (Wed 7/2) -
though it is on the call of Senate President Pro Tem Burton.
Not clear how this impacts presentation of the Senate
Republican budget proposal, which originally last week was to
be considered and voted on possibly on Thursday sometime. That
may all change if reports of a budget deal are true.
* ASSEMBLY: The Assembly is scheduled to meet at 10:30 AM, to
consider and vote on the Assembly Republican budget proposal.
The proposal has little chance of passage. No reports of any
budget deal close on the Assembly side. Not certain if the
Assembly Democrats will attempt another vote on their version
of the budget - and much also depends if the Senate is
actually close to a budget deal.
FOR MORE INFORMATION ABOUT THIS REPORT
* This is a report for Californians with developmental (&
other disabilities), families, providers and other advocates,
from the California Coalition of United Cerebral Palsy
Associations, a link to the California Community Advocacy
Network.
* If you would like to get on this distribution (and
conversely, get off of it) please send an email with that
request to: martyomoto@rcip.com. Sharing information is
part of our organizing effort. Please feel free to forward or
copy this (attribution is nice). We're all in this together!
Marty Omoto, advocate/brother of Alana, sister with
developmental disabilities
CA Coalition of United Cerebral Palsy Associations
1225 8th Street Suite 480 Sacramento, CA 95814
916/446-0013 (NEW phone number!)
NEW fax number: 916/446-0026 email: martyomoto@rcip.com
Coalition Chair: Philip Ksarjian (UCP of Greater Sacramento)
Past Chair: Ron Cohen (UCP of LA, Ventura and Santa Barbara
Counties)