Mentally Ill More Likely to be Victims

Mentally Ill are Often Victims of Violent Crime

A British study has joined earlier research is demonstrating that, contrary to media stereotypes and the rhetoric of forced treatment advocates, people with psychiatric disabilities are far more apt to be victims, not perpetrators of violent crime.

Murder risk 'higher for mentally ill'

The mentally ill are frequently victims of violent crime
BBC Online News December 21, 2001

Mentally ill patients are six times more likely to be murdered than the general population, researchers have found. The mentally ill also have higher death rates from suicide and accidental causes.

The researchers, including the government's National Director for Mental Health in England, Professor Louis Appleby, said public and media attention usually focuses on the mentally ill as dangerous and as perpetrators of homicides.

Writing in the Lancet, they say more attention should be paid to the risk mentally ill people face of becoming murder victims themselves.

Death risks

The researchers from the University of Manchester and Aarhus, Denmark, looked at information from the Danish Psychiatric Case Register, and the Danish National Register for Causes of Death for 72,208 people. All were on the psychiatric register, which records details of people admitted to hospital between 1973 and 1993.

Deaths up to 31 December 1993 were looked at and researchers used statistical analysis to compare death rates between people with different mental illnesses. Twenty-five per cent of deaths were from unnatural causes. Of those 1% were homicides, 26% were accidental deaths and 73% were suicides. It was found mentally ill patients were six times more likely to be murdered than people without mental illness.

Men with schizophrenia and people with affective psychosis (severe depression with delusions and hallucinations) have an even higher risk of being murdered.

The highest risks of death by both murder and accident were in patients with alcoholism and in patients who were drug users. Drug users also had the highest risks of suicide.

Risk factors

In the Lancet paper, the researchers said although high risk of murder and those using drugs and alcohol might have been predicted, the reason for the high risk for male schizophrenics and those with affective psychosis was less clear. They speculate their risk could be increased by factors including living in places with high murder rates such as inner cities, others are hostile to them because of symptoms such as irritability or paranoia, or they may be killed by other mentally ill people they come into contact with.

The researchers write: "Whatever the cause, the public and media, who have historically been concerned about the risk that the mentally ill present to others, should be made aware of the vulnerability of these patients to the violence of others."

Professor Appleby told BBC News Online: "The first thing is to get the information out, because these are the sort of things clinicians need to think about."

"The other message is that this is the kind of information anti-stigma groups need, and allows us to tackle the issue head on."

He said reducing alcohol and drug misuse amongst the mentally ill was crucial because it would reduce their risk of being the victim of a homicide.

'Easy prey'

Marjorie Wallace, chef executive of the mental health charity Sane, said: "We have long been aware of the hidden fatalities among those suffering from mental illness and the greater risks arising through their own physical neglect.

"Much emphasis has been placed on the very rare headline cases where a mentally ill person has killed a stranger, while the real danger is to mentally ill people themselves.

"They are placed in tower blocks, hard to let flats and hostels in poorer areas, where they are easy prey to drug addicts and petty criminals.

"In our enthusiasm for every mentally ill person, however vulnerable, to live in the community, we have overlooked the need to protect them and their families as well as to educate the public."

Source: BBC

----------------------------------------

Mentally ill unlikely to commit murder

BBC News Online January 5, 1999

Murders committed by mentally ill people are not on the increase, despite popular belief, psychiatrists have claimed. People who have drunk too much or taken drugs are more likely to kill someone, they said.

The finding comes in a study by the Royal College of Psychiatrists (RCPsych), which found a steady decline in the proportion of murders committed by people with mental disorders between 1957 and 1995.

It concludes that people are more likely to win the National Lottery jackpot than to die at the hand of a stranger with a mental illness.

It also says the finding proves that the care in the community scheme is not a "dangerous experiment" and should not be reversed.

However, high-profile murder cases involving schizophrenic patients in community care have led the public to fear attacks from mentally ill people and the government to review the scheme.

Mental health charities said that the success or otherwise of care in the community should not be judged on statistics such as homicide rates. And the Zito Trust, which campaigns for reforms of mental health care, questioned the accuracy of the study's findings.

Risks to the public

Launching the RCPsych study, college president Dr Robert Kendell, said: "If any one of us in this room is frightened of being murdered, the people we should worry about are people who are drunk or intoxicated."

The study was carried out by Professor Pamela Taylor and Professor John Gunn of the Institute of Psychiatry in London.

It examined Home Office crime statistics from a 38-year period, and found that the proportion of murders committed by mentally ill patients had declined by about three per cent each year.

The actual number of homicides committed by individuals with mental disorders peaked at 130 in 1972, but since then had fallen steadily to 60 in 1995.

......

Source: BBC

Opinions expressed in this web site do not necessarily reflect the views of NAMI Santa Cruz County, NAMI California or any affiliated organizations. We attempt to present a balanced perspective on issues by presenting multiple viewpoints.

FAIR USE NOTICE: This may contain copyrighted (©) material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Such material is made available to advance understanding of ecological, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, moral, ethical, and social justice issues, etc. It is believed that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml If you wish to use copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.